But some free games you do get to keep. I can tell you with certainty you got to keep Stacking, Lead & Gold and Red Faction: Battlegrounds, at the very least (well, I still have them, and they still work, and I'm no longer a Plus subscriber, so...

). Oh, and you also keep any free Minis (like Flying Hamster) and PS1 games (like Guilty Gear) that are on offer, as well as all free themes and avatars, premium or no.
I guess it depends on the game.
So, some free games, free Minis, free PS1 games, free themes and avatars, and discounts on new games? That's not too shabby.
...