Zitat:
Judged on its own merits, it's good. As a remake of the 1998 anime or an adaptation of the manga, it's awful.
Part of the problem is trying to cram so many events into such a short movie. We barely get a glimpse into Guts' past, and nothing about Griffith or Caska, which is central to understanding them. We don't see all but one of the battles the Hawks win, many of which are vital to the story. And even that lone victory is abbreviated. No one in the Band of the Hawk except Griffith, Guts, and Caska gets any attention. Judeau gets a few speaking lines and is a non-entity. Pippin and Rickert aren't even introduced by name and spend a few seconds in the background of scenes.
Kurze Suche scheint das noch zu unterstreichen. Hab die generelle Resonanz als negativer eingeschätzt, aber es war vermutlich dann wirklich nur konzentriert von "Fanboys" oder so. Wer weiß.